CITIZENS   FOR  LIMITED  TAXATION
and the
Citizens Economic Research Foundation

 

CLT UPDATE
Sunday, March 30, 2003

Jill Stein's rich friends
"aren't paying their fair share of taxes"


Here is the latest update on how many Massachusetts liberals are taking the option of paying higher state income taxes at the old rate of 5.85 percent, rather than the new 5.3 percent rate imposed by the mean-spirited taxpayers.

According to the Department of Revenue, so far 504 of 1,139,777 state filers have opted to pay the higher rate, for a total of an additional $55,636, which means most of them pay very little income tax to begin with.

For those of you keeping score at home, that 504 number translates into .004 of 1 percent of filers - odd, considering that 41 percent of the voters claimed in the referendum that they were against cutting the rate to 5.3 percent.

The Boston Herald
Sunday, March 30, 2003
The Buzz [Excerpt]
Voting with wallets


"We believe there are better ways to do it, without massive cuts," [Jill Stein] said. "I know a lot of rich people who say they aren't paying their fair share of taxes and they are behind this."

The MetroWest Daily News
Sunday, March 30, 2003
Stein takes on Romney budget


In the oh-so-prosperous '90s, cities and towns across Massachusetts built new schools as though there were no tomorrow....

But the exceedingly generous 60 percent to 90 percent subsidies offered by the state during the boom times helped drive up the expenditure sheet that now hangs like an albatross around our collective necks. The state borrowed money to underwrite local school building programs, in the amount of $11 billion in outstanding commitments....

On reflection, it's not surprising towns didn't bother to stint on the size and quality of the schools they were building. When the other guy is picking up 90 percent of the check, filet mignon looks awfully good.

A Patriot Ledger editorial
Saturday, March 29, 2003
School building aid coming to an end


Chip Ford's CLT Commentary

Jill Stein, former gubernatorial candidate representing the socialist Green Party and now leading the charge for her new organization, Massachusetts Coalition for Healthy Communities, has declared she knows "a lot of rich people who say they aren't paying their fair share of taxes" and are behind her push for higher taxes.

I certainly hope that "lot of rich people" doesn't exceed the 504 who so far have chosen CLT's voluntary tax check-off, which appears on this year's income tax return, or they'd be shameless hypocrites.

But those 504 who chose paying the higher rate, according to today's Boston Herald, only provided "an additional $55,636, which means most of them pay very little income tax to begin with." That doesn't sound very much like that "lot of rich people" to which Ms. Stein referred.

So what's going on here?

Ms. Stein is standing on pretty shaky legs -- unless she gets that "lot of rich people" she knows who "aren't paying their fair share" to put their money where their socialist politics are. Every one of them could easily, voluntarily, pay more of their "fair share" this year, if they were honest. Somebody is lying here: either Ms. Stein or the "rich people" she knows.

I just don't believe her, and thanks to the CLT voluntary tax check-off, two weeks from Wednesday we won't have to accept her deceptions. Any pretension of support for a tax hike will be lost to her and to the rest of the Gimme Lobby.

Never mind polls and surveys and rhetoric; hard factual evidence is pouring in.

Actions speak louder than words. The tax-me-more crowd -- all 1,055,181 of them who voted against our tax rollback, the 41 percent who insisted that they "didn't need or want a tax cut" -- still has its chance to prove a commitment to higher taxes.

So far, only 504 have demonstrated it when it counts.

What a collection of hypocritical phonies the remainder are.

It's either that ... or more than a million voters came to recognize their mistake, now admit it and belatedly support our tax rollback.

Either way, we know that so far all but 504 of them did in fact "need and want a tax cut."

Even when they no longer have to take it, they've freely chosen not to give it up.

This is demonstrably overwhelming evidence of almost-unanimous public opposition to any tax increase whatsoever.

Even our erstwhile tax rollback opponents have now asserted, "enough is enough!"

Chip Ford


The MetroWest Daily News
Sunday, March 30, 2003

Stein takes on Romney budget
By Shannon Haley Daggett


Jill Stein, the Green Party candidate in last year's race for governor, will talk about Gov. Mitt Romney's budget proposals Tuesday at the VFW Hall.

Stein will be one of four political activists slated to discuss what critical services are endangered, and where they see room to make cuts.

The public forum starts at 7 p.m. at 113 West Central St.

Stein is representing the nonprofit, nonpartisan Massachusetts Coalition for Healthy Communities.

The other speakers are Phil Mamber, president of Massachusetts Senior Action; Iris Vicencio-Garaygay, environmental director of MassPirg; and David Schildmeier from the Massachusetts Nurses Association.

The group putting together Tuesday's forum includes Green Party members, Democrats and Independents "who are alarmed about fiscal irresponsibility at the state level and fear that nothing will change unless we mount a strong grass-roots organization," said Lesley Stillwell, a Natick resident whose been planning the forum.

"We believe there are better ways to do it, without massive cuts," she said. "I know a lot of rich people who say they aren't paying their fair share of taxes and they are behind this."

Stillwell said the budget reductions need to be made, but without cutting critical services.

"There is a lot of spending that is truly not necessary. A lot of bureaucratic waste," she said.

Stillwell defined "healthier communities" as an outlook that protects vital services, including services for the homeless and those with health problems.

"I hope that most of the towns in Massachusetts will continue this and educate people how it can be done without going through their pocketbooks, standing together and being a force for change."

Return to top


The Patriot Ledger
Saturday, March 29, 2003

Editorial
School building aid coming to an end


In the oh-so-prosperous '90s, cities and towns across Massachusetts built new schools as though there were no tomorrow.

That turned out to be great planning, because a tomorrow in which great gobs of education aid from the state is available is disappearing fast.

Schools are considered a vital community resource. So when Massachusetts taxpayers read about the sorry condition of the state's finances and wonder where the money went, it's a safe bet they don't think about school buildings. But the exceedingly generous 60 percent to 90 percent subsidies offered by the state during the boom times helped drive up the expenditure sheet that now hangs like an albatross around our collective necks. The state borrowed money to underwrite local school building programs, in the amount of $11 billion in outstanding commitments.

That's a lot of money. It's perhaps the best example of how easily money is spent when it's flowing in. Every community has an old school or two; some have several. And legislators were more than happy to deliver that kind of gravy to their constituents. As a result, building programs escalated. An edifice complex took over. 

In Scituate, the new Jenkins School is built but not yet open because voters have refused to pass an override to pay to operate the school. On Saturday the town will vote on another override attempt.

On reflection, it's not surprising towns didn't bother to stint on the size and quality of the schools they were building. When the other guy is picking up 90 percent of the check, filet mignon looks awfully good.

Early this year the state Education Department slapped a moratorium on new requests for school building projects. The state would concentrate on projects already listed. Legislators rushed to postpone the moratorium until June 30, which is a critical date for Quincy and other communities.

The extension will be a one-time event. It may seem unfair that some communities built several new schools in recent years while others were late to the table. But fairness is not the issue. The state is broke.

This week House Speaker Tom Finneran said the school building debt - which stretches out decades - is potentially another Big Dig for the commonwealth. "That's not a good thing," said Finneran. No, it's not. It's disastrous.

Return to top


NOTE: In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. section 107, this material is distributed without profit or payment to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving this information for non-profit research and educational purposes only. For more information go to: http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml


Return to CLT Updates page

Return to CLT home page